02 March 2012
A new threat to media freedoms
Writers of the world, beware. A new threat to our freedom of speech is looming and, for once, I am not inveighing against the Official Secrets Act.
Over recent years the UK has rightly earned a pungent reputation as the libel capital of the world. And now it appears that this wonderful practice is going "offshore".
How did this whole mess begin? It turned out that someone in the Middle East could take exception to a book written and published about them in the USA. US law, somewhat surprisingly considering its current parlous state, provided no route to sue. However, some bright legal spark decided that the UK courts could be used for redress, provided the offending book had been sold in the UK - even if only a handful of second-hand books had been sold over Amazon.co.uk - and Mr Justice Eady helped the process along magnificently.
And so was born the concept of "libel tourism". Satirical current affairs magazine Private Eye has long been campaigning against this, other UK news outlets gradually followed suit, and the UK government is finally taking steps to rein in these egregious, if lucrative, legal practices.
But, hey, that's precisely when your offshore crown dependencies, otherwise known as British tax havens, come into their own. The UK has for years turned a blind eye to the dubious financial practices of these islands, the most geographically convenient being the Channel Islands and the Isle of Man, where the attitude to self-regulation makes the dealings of the Square Mile look positively Vestal.
Now it appears that Guernsey is looking to become a hub of another lucrative offshore practice: libel tourism.
Guernsey has its own parliament - the States - and can make its own laws. So as the libel door closes on the UK mainland, a firm of offshore tax lawyers has identified a wonderful business opportunity.
Jason Romer is the managing partner and intellectual property specialist at the large "wealth management" legal firm Collas Crill. According to his firm's website, he also, coincidentally, sits on the island's Commercial IP Steering Group and the Drafting Sub-Committee, and is thus conveniently on hand to ease the new legislation through the States.
Also coincidentally, he appears to be an enthusiastic advocate of Eady's infamous "super-injunction" regime which has had such a chillingly expensive effect on the British media in the last decade.
So, if this law is passed, anyone, anywhere around the world will be able (if they can afford it) to register their "image rights" in Guernsey. These rights can even last indefinitely after the original owner's death.
This means that anyone, anywhere, who feels that their "image" has been inappropriately reproduced/copied/traduced/pirated - the correct legal terminology is hazy - can then sue through the Guernsey courts for redress. This could potentially be a powerful new global tool for the suppression of free speech. As public outcry swells internationally against the US IP laws, SOPA and PIPA, and across Europe against the utterly undemocratic ACTA, this new law is a giant leap precisely in the wrong direction.
Guernsey, my island of birth, has changed out of all recognition over the last thirty years. Ever since the 1980s infestation of offshore bankers and trust fund lawyers, it has been tarmac-ed over by greed and social division. Before then it was proud of its egalitarianism, Norman-French heritage, beautifully anachronistic pace of life, and an economy based on tomatoes and tourism.
Now, if this law is passed, it will be known for its economy based on rotten financial apples and offshore libel tourism.
I just wanted to get that out of my system now - while I can still freely express my thoughts and before the island can sue me for damaging its "image rights"....
Over recent years the UK has rightly earned a pungent reputation as the libel capital of the world. And now it appears that this wonderful practice is going "offshore".
How did this whole mess begin? It turned out that someone in the Middle East could take exception to a book written and published about them in the USA. US law, somewhat surprisingly considering its current parlous state, provided no route to sue. However, some bright legal spark decided that the UK courts could be used for redress, provided the offending book had been sold in the UK - even if only a handful of second-hand books had been sold over Amazon.co.uk - and Mr Justice Eady helped the process along magnificently.
And so was born the concept of "libel tourism". Satirical current affairs magazine Private Eye has long been campaigning against this, other UK news outlets gradually followed suit, and the UK government is finally taking steps to rein in these egregious, if lucrative, legal practices.
Now it appears that Guernsey is looking to become a hub of another lucrative offshore practice: libel tourism.
Guernsey has its own parliament - the States - and can make its own laws. So as the libel door closes on the UK mainland, a firm of offshore tax lawyers has identified a wonderful business opportunity.
Jason Romer is the managing partner and intellectual property specialist at the large "wealth management" legal firm Collas Crill. According to his firm's website, he also, coincidentally, sits on the island's Commercial IP Steering Group and the Drafting Sub-Committee, and is thus conveniently on hand to ease the new legislation through the States.
So, if this law is passed, anyone, anywhere around the world will be able (if they can afford it) to register their "image rights" in Guernsey. These rights can even last indefinitely after the original owner's death.
This means that anyone, anywhere, who feels that their "image" has been inappropriately reproduced/copied/traduced/pirated - the correct legal terminology is hazy - can then sue through the Guernsey courts for redress. This could potentially be a powerful new global tool for the suppression of free speech. As public outcry swells internationally against the US IP laws, SOPA and PIPA, and across Europe against the utterly undemocratic ACTA, this new law is a giant leap precisely in the wrong direction.
Guernsey, my island of birth, has changed out of all recognition over the last thirty years. Ever since the 1980s infestation of offshore bankers and trust fund lawyers, it has been tarmac-ed over by greed and social division. Before then it was proud of its egalitarianism, Norman-French heritage, beautifully anachronistic pace of life, and an economy based on tomatoes and tourism.
Now, if this law is passed, it will be known for its economy based on rotten financial apples and offshore libel tourism.
I just wanted to get that out of my system now - while I can still freely express my thoughts and before the island can sue me for damaging its "image rights"....
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e55090303188330163025153ad970d
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A new threat to media freedoms:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e55090303188330163025153ad970d
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference A new threat to media freedoms:
The comments to this entry are closed.
Blog
Speaking Experience
Talks
- The Big Dig Journalism Conference, Copenhagen
- Cambridge Union Society Talk (January 2011) on PSTV,
On PSTV: Sky 201 or 203 - CIJ Talk, London, July 2011
- How the Light Gets In - speaking in Hay-on-Wye, May 30 2011
Forthcoming talks at the end of May. - Frontline Club/New Statesman (FCNS) whistleblower debate with Julian Assange
- New York INN conference: How the world changed after 9/11
A televised symposium in New York, September 2010. - Bits of Freedom Talk, Amsterdam, September 2010
Talking about happy subjects to a very cool, switched-on crowd of geeks and activists. A good evening! - WikiLeaks Discussion Panel with Julian Assange, HAR NL 2009
WikiLeaks discussion and the need for whistleblowing. - The Secret Garden Party, UK 2010
Speaking at The Forum in the SGP 2010. - Talking about Totalitarianism at ETH-0, January 2010
- Canadian Tour
Finally! - Canadian Speaking Tour, May 2009
National tour starts on 22 May 2009 - Make Wars History Campaign
The launch of Make Wars History, January 2008 - ETH0 Hacker Camp, January 2009
Hacker conference in NL - Talks in California, September 2008
Two speaking events in California - Ethics Talk at a School
Talk at Bishops Stortford High School - McKinney and Machon in Amsterdam
Cynthia McKinney and Annie Machon speak in Amsterdam - Introducing Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney in London, 2007
Introducing Cynthia McKinney in London - IT Defense Conference, Hamburg January 2008
Spying meets cutting edge IT - International Islamic Fair, Malaysia 2007
Major international conference
TV
- Book Review on "Epilogue"
- Libya, MI6, and torture - interview on Press TV
- RTTV Interview: Libya - the perfect storm
- RTTV interview: Murdoch's ex-CEO arrested
- Press TV interview about spies and the media, June 2011
- RTTV interview on the royal wedding and arrest of UK activists
- RTTV interview, 23 March 2011 about the war in Libya and the dilemma facing the West
- RTTV interview - dancing with the devil - how not to deal with "rogue" states
- Libya Interview, RTTV 23 February 2011
- Interview about the Russian spy ring on Russia Today TV, 30th June 2010
Photograph Album
- For publicity, or whatever... Many thanks to Chris Carr for most of these wonderful photos.
Articles
- The Bureau of Investigative Journalism article
- Guantanamo Files: was Bin Hamlili really an MI6 source?
- The Guardian, 24 January 2011
- Legal doublethink re whistleblowers - my CPBF article, July 2006
- Sunday Telegraph Article, August 2010
- August 2005 Guardian Article
- March 2005 CPBF Article on the Shayler Trial
- AltVoices Article, June 2007
- The UK Spies: Ineffective, Unethical and Unaccountable
- August 2007 Mail on Sunday Article
Art & Culture
Organisations
Support
Thankyou!
Categories
- 9/11
- Accountability
- ACTA
- Big Brother
- Books
- CCTV
- CIA
- Civil Liberties
- Current Affairs
- Democracy
- Dr Kelly
- Economics
- Extradition
- FBI
- Film
- Gaddafi
- GCHQ
- GMC
- Guernsey
- Intelligence
- IP
- IRA
- ISC
- IT
- Law
- LEAP
- Libya
- Machon
- Manning
- Mauger
- Media
- Mercenaries
- MI5
- MI6
- Mossad
- National security
- Northern Ireland
- NSA
- Open source
- OSA
- Police
- Politics
- Psychiatry
- RTTV
- Science
- Shayler
- Spies
- Surveillance
- Technology
- Television
- Terrorism
- Torture
- Voting computers
- War
- Whistleblowers
- Wikileaks
Bleats
Recent Posts
- A new threat to media freedoms
- DoubleThink Disorder - a new pathology
- "Subversion" old and new
- A Tale of Two Cases
- One man's terrorist is another man's activist
- Judicial rendition - the UK-US extradition treaty is a farce
- Mediafabric conference in Prague
- Fascism 2012 - the ongoing merger of the corporate and the state
- The Big Dig Journalism Conference, Copenhagen
- Book Review on "Epilogue"
Interviews
- Interview in Cambridge with PSTV, January 2011
- Varsity newspaper interview, February 2011
- Interview in The Independent about female spies, November 2006
- Interview about the Russian spy ring on Russia Today TV, 30th June 2010
- Interview about the Russian spy swap on Russia Today TV, 8th July 2010
- Interview with Ryan JW Smith, July 2010
- Emel Magazine, November 2007
- New Statesman Article, August 2008
- The Point of No Return
- Interview with Francis Wheen, 1999
Bookshelf
- "Spies, Lies and Whistleblowers" - subversion chapter
- Freedom of Expression in the UK - Article 19 and Liberty
- "Spies, Lies, and Whistleblowers" - the full text of the book
- Spies, Lies and Whistleblowers - a BitTorrent download
- GMC Determinations about the Steven Lomax case
- Operation Shadower - illegal MI5 bugging of left-wing UK journalist
- The Israeli Embassy Two - a gross miscarriage of justice
- Spies, Lies and Whistleblowers - the Gaddafi Plot chapters
- May 2005 - The Times
- Spies Lies and Whistleblowers
http://www.anniemachon.com/annie_machon/2012/03/a-new-threat-to-media-freedoms.html
Comments